The
following is the abstract for the lecture I presented
at the November 2009 at the Known World Dance Symposium
VII at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. The
presentation included a variety of slides.
Abstract:
"To every thing there is a season, and a time
to every purpose under the heaven[s]… A time to weep,
and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to
dance…", so says the King James Version
of the Bible, and most translations before and after
have agreed. While Salome's dancing might have cost
John the Baptist his head, and King David's dancing
and leaping might have disgusted his wife, surely Ecclesiastes
3:4, in stating that there is "a time to dance,"
could not be more clear. And yet, it could be more
specific. Ecclesiastes 3:4, and the Bible generally,
gives very little advice as to when exactly
is the time for dancing; says nothing at all about
what sort of dances one should dance; and offers
contradictory examples of how one should dance.
(Ref. 1) These biblical gray areas, compounded by the
difficulty of describing ephemeral movement in words,
have generated controversy since the early days of
the Church. Yet, it was the Sabbatarian and behavioural
reform movements of the Protestant Reformation in England
that made opposition to dancing a matter of State interest.
Carried to North America by the Puritans and other
religious refugees, the questions of when, what, and
how to dance have continued to perplex and confound
clergy, parents, and the State… even to today. Comparing
early modern views on dancing with more contemporary
dance debates reveals patterns in the way people define
and distinguish between appropriate and inappropriate
manners of dancing.
References:
1.
God and friends, Ecclesiastes 3:4, King James
Version, available at GodRules.net
(Accessed 21 November 2007).
For
more of my papers please return to:
Papers, Essays, and Lectures.
|